Dating back to approximately 1858–1861, this remarkable historic residence in Georgiana, Alabama, is reportedly the oldest surviving home in town. Built by Reverend Pitt S. Milner, the founder of Georgiana, the property offers approximately 4,400 square feet of living space, five bedrooms, four bathrooms, and a little over two acres of mature gardens and established trees.
Constructed with locally sourced heart pine, the two-story home preserves architectural details that reflect the character of traditional Southern residences from the mid-19th century. Its full-width front porch, double entry doors, wide foyers, high ceilings, and wood flooring give the property a distinctive historic appearance.
The front porch stretches across the entire width of the house, creating an inviting entrance beneath a traditional roof supported by substantial columns. Upstairs, an originally open balcony was later enclosed as a screened porch. Historical photographs reportedly show the balcony’s earlier appearance, offering an opportunity to appreciate how the property has evolved over the years.
Inside, the double front doors open into a spacious foyer that extends through the length of the home. A second wide foyer upstairs provides a similar sense of openness on the upper level. Original heart pine construction and traditional wood floors contribute to the residence’s historic atmosphere.
The main floor includes a living room, dining room, kitchen, two bedrooms, one full bathroom, one half bathroom, and a mudroom. The central foyer connects these spaces and creates a practical arrangement for everyday living while retaining the layout of an older Southern home.
The upper level offers three additional bedrooms, a second kitchen, one full bathroom, and a storage room that could potentially be adapted for another use. With kitchens on both floors, the property offers flexibility for different household arrangements, extended family, or separate living areas, subject to verification of the existing systems and permitted use.
The home’s approximately 4,400 square feet provide generous interior space, but buyers should pay particular attention to the heating and cooling arrangements. According to the listing, central heating and air conditioning are available upstairs, while the downstairs does not have central heating or cooling. Future improvements may therefore be necessary to provide consistent comfort throughout the residence.
Outside, the property features a little over two acres of established Southern landscaping. Mature azaleas, camellias, magnolias, and large oak trees create a setting that has developed over many decades. The home sits well back from the road, with the surrounding gardens and trees adding to its traditional country-estate character.
There is also an interesting local story associated with the residence. According to folklore mentioned in the listing, the home is believed to have inspired Hank Williams’ song “The Mansion on the Hill.” This connection has not been established as a documented historical fact, but it adds another layer of local interest to the property’s story.
Listed for $185,000, this Georgiana residence offers an unusual combination of approximately 4,400 square feet, five bedrooms, four bathrooms, two kitchens, and more than two acres of mature landscaping. Its reported connection to the town’s founding and its surviving heart pine construction make it particularly distinctive.
Because of its age, a thorough inspection of the foundation, framing, roof, wood siding, porches, windows, plumbing, electrical systems, and existing heating equipment is essential. Buyers should also obtain estimates for installing suitable downstairs climate control and review available historical documentation to verify the home’s reported construction date and background.
For buyers interested in preserving a piece of Alabama history, this 1850s farmhouse offers substantial space, traditional architecture, and mature grounds with plenty of historic character.
If you’re interested in learning more about this property, please contact the listing agent through the Zillow link provided below the original property photos.

































View the original listing on Zillow
